Liberty Ohio
Is the exclusionary rule good public policy?
The exclusionary rule, which dictates that evidence found in violation of a defendant's 4th Amendment rights, is hardly uncontroversial. It's application often results in guilty parties going free. On the other hand, perhaps it can be justified because it deters police infrigements on privacy, and thereby protects our liberty.
Resolve this problem below. For reference, see Mapp v. Ohio, Wolf v. Colorado and progeny.
No this is not an exam question. I am a law student/buff interested in what people have to say. And I am aware of the numerous exceptions to this rule, but for the purposes of this answer, assume that evidence collected in violation of a defendant's 4th Amendment rights will always be excluded.
This is a case of two wrong supposedly making a right. The criminal did wrong. The police did wrong. Therefore the evidence against the criminal is thrown out and if that was needed to convict him, he gets to walk.
Its intent was to keep the cops honest and protect the individuals fourth amendment rights. However, I feel the rule is wrong.
There are TWO violations of the law. If evidence is found proving the criminal is guilty, it should be allowed. If the evidence was gotten illegally and in violation of the Fourth Amendment, then the person who did it should ALSO be punished.
Example. A man murders a child and buries the body. There is a lot of suspicion but no proof. One cop wiretaps the man's phone without a court order and gets a conversation on tape of the man saying where he buried the body. They go look and find the body and arrest the man. Now, with the rule in place, the man gets to go free unless they find other evidence not connected to the wiretap.
Get rid of the rule. Now the child killer goes to prison. As for the cop, he gets tried for illegal wiretaps and he also goes to prison. Since the survival rate of cops in prisons is not so hot, most cops would try their best not to do anything illegal in their pursuit of justice.
 |
 RPPC WEST LIBERTY OHIO CAVE INTERIOR VINTAGE POSTCARD $13.99 Time Remaining: 16h 23m Buy It Now for only: $13.99 |
 Vintage Castle Piatt Mac A Cheek Postcard West Liberty Ohio $1.29 Time Remaining: 20h 34m Buy It Now for only: $2.49 |
 Entrance BuildingOhio Caverns West LibertyOhio $1.79 Time Remaining: 1d 13h 26m Buy It Now for only: $1.79 |
 Shelter PavilionOhio Caverns West LibertyOhio $1.79 Time Remaining: 1d 13h 26m Buy It Now for only: $1.79 |
 061 oh girard ohio shelter house veterans liberty memorial park NICE postcard $2.79 Time Remaining: 1d 13h 33m |
 RPPC HOCKING COUNTY OHIO WEST LIBERTY CANTWELL CLIFF OH $9.99 Time Remaining: 1d 16h 59m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 |
 Dillonvale Ohio Jefferson Co Liberty Street RPPC real photo postcard 1907 $34.99 Time Remaining: 1d 17h 56m |
 RPPC BUTLER OHIO NORTH LIBERTY PRIMARY SCHOOL CLASS 10 ANTIQUE VINTAGE POSTCARD $29.99 Time Remaining: 2d 11h 14m Buy It Now for only: $29.99 |
 Union Furnace OH Ohio 1909 RPPC Postcard Liberty Band with Instruments $22.50 Time Remaining: 2d 13h 56m Buy It Now for only: $22.50 |
 Lovers Lane West Liberty Ohio OH 1910s $6.00 Time Remaining: 2d 15h 33m |
 1907 CADIZ Ohio Postcard Greeting SHIP Statue Liberty $6.00 Time Remaining: 2d 16h 48m Buy It Now for only: $6.00 |
 RPPC OHIO CAVERNS WEST LIBERTY OHIO CAVE INTERIOR ROOMS $9.99 Time Remaining: 3d 6h 34m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 |
 RPPC OHIO CAVERNS WEST LIBERTY OHIO CAVE INTERIOR ROOMS $9.99 Time Remaining: 3d 6h 35m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 |
 Mac o chee Castle West Liberty Ohio Postcard $8.50 Time Remaining: 3d 12h 43m Buy It Now for only: $8.50 |
 RPPC Caverns West Liberty Ohio 1927 $20.00 Time Remaining: 4d 9h 43m Buy It Now for only: $20.00 |
 Vintage Post Card Night View Liberty Street Vermillion Ohio 1948 Lake Erie $2.85 Time Remaining: 4d 10h 13m |
 GIBSONVILLE NC SCARCE PENNANT POSTCARD 1922 TO MOUNT LIBERTY OHIO $1.04 (2 Bids) Time Remaining: 4d 14h 23m |
 VINTAGE POSTCARD LIBERTY STREET VERMILLION OHIO $5.00 Time Remaining: 5d 16h 12m Buy It Now for only: $5.00 |
 Crystal King Caves West Liberty Ohio Vintage Postcard $3.99 Time Remaining: 6d 7h 58m Buy It Now for only: $3.99 |
 Piatt Mac A Cheek Chateau West Liberty Ohio Postcard $3.99 Time Remaining: 6d 8h 1m Buy It Now for only: $3.99 |
 WESTERVILLE OHIO OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY WEST LIBERTY OH ANTIQUE VINTAGE POSTCARD $16.99 Time Remaining: 6d 14h 56m Buy It Now for only: $16.99 |
 LINCOLN AVENUE LOOKING EAST FROM LIBERTY STREET DELAWARE OHIO FREE SHIPPING $9.99 Time Remaining: 6d 20h 28m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 |
 OH WEST LIBERTY OHIO CAVERNS CRYSTAL KING EARLY T50999 $3.75 Time Remaining: 7d 13h 57m Buy It Now for only: $3.75 |
 OH363 Castle Piatt Mac A Cheek West Liberty Ohio Postcard $5.99 Time Remaining: 8d 18h 24m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 |
 West Liberty Ohio VINTAGE Crystal Sea Caverns Curteich $6.99 Time Remaining: 8d 19h 38m Buy It Now for only: $6.99 |
 REAL PHOTO POSTCARD ANTIQUE VINTAGE RPPC WEST LIBERTY OHIO CAVE INTERIOR OH $13.99 Time Remaining: 10d 5h 43m Buy It Now for only: $13.99 |
 RPPC Entrance to Ohio Caverns West LibertyOhio $1.79 Time Remaining: 10d 19h 41m Buy It Now for only: $1.79 |
 RPPC Ohio Caverns West LibertyOhio 1 $1.79 Time Remaining: 10d 19h 41m Buy It Now for only: $1.79 |
 RPPC Ohio Caverns West LibertyOhio 2 $1.79 Time Remaining: 10d 19h 41m Buy It Now for only: $1.79 |
 RPPC LIBERTY CENTER OHIO STREET SCENE VINTAGE POSTCARD $39.99 Time Remaining: 10d 20h 55m Buy It Now for only: $39.99 |
 Maries Candies West Liberty OH Ohio ad postcard $5.99 Time Remaining: 11d 13h 50m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 |
 OLD POSTCARD LIBERTY MEMORIAL PARK GIRARD OHIO $5.99 Time Remaining: 11d 17h 14m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 |
 GIRARD OHIO DOWNTOWN LIBERTY STREET ANTIQUE VINTAGE POSTCARD SHIPPING PORT PA $24.99 Time Remaining: 12d 12h 28m Buy It Now for only: $24.99 |
 OLD POSTCARD FAIRYLAND OHIO CAVERNS WEST LIBERTY OH $6.99 Time Remaining: 12d 13h 2m Buy It Now for only: $6.99 |
 West Liberty Ohio Postcard Ohio Caverns Colonnade Interior View c1940s Unused $4.50 Time Remaining: 12d 14h 57m Buy It Now for only: $4.50 |
 RPPC WEST LIBERTY OHIO STONE BRIDGE VINTAGE POSTCARD OH $13.99 Time Remaining: 13d 11h 46m Buy It Now for only: $13.99 |
 RPPC WEST LIBERTY OHIO OLD MANS CAVE VINTAGE POSTCARD $16.99 Time Remaining: 13d 11h 47m Buy It Now for only: $16.99 |
 Ohio Caverns West Liberty Ohio RPPC $1.80 Time Remaining: 13d 13h 30m Buy It Now for only: $1.80 |
 1910 RPPC POSTCARD RR TRAIN CONDUCTOR WEST LIBERTY OHIO $24.96 Time Remaining: 13d 20h 32m Buy It Now for only: $24.96 |
 VINTAGE POSTCARD OHIO CAVERNS WEST LIBERTY OHIO $5.00 Time Remaining: 15d 16h 36m Buy It Now for only: $5.00 |
 Admin Bldg West Liberty State College Wheeling WV Ohio $2.98 Time Remaining: 18d 5h 48m Buy It Now for only: $2.98 |
 RPPC WEST LIBERTY OHIO PIATT CASTLE MAC A CHEEK CHATEAU $24.99 Time Remaining: 19d 15h 58m Buy It Now for only: $24.99 |
 WEST LIBERTY OHIO RPPC POSTCARD OHIO CAVERNS $5.59 Time Remaining: 21d 9h 29m Buy It Now for only: $5.59 |
 RPPC MOUNT MT LIBERTY OHIO RESIDENCE STREET SCENE VINTAGE REAL PHOTO POSTCARD $39.99 Time Remaining: 21d 15h 34m Buy It Now for only: $39.99 |
 West Liberty Ohio OH 1930s RPPC Ohio Caverns Stone Gate $18.99 Time Remaining: 21d 18h 15m Buy It Now for only: $18.99 |
 VERMILLION OHIO ON LAKE ERIE NIGHT VIEW OF LIBERTY ST $9.99 Time Remaining: 22d 7h 30m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 |
 c1930 WEST LIBERTY OH Postcard OHIO CAVERNS $4.95 Time Remaining: 22d 11h 33m Buy It Now for only: $4.95 |
 Piatt Castles West Liberty Ohio Postcard Folder $5.00 Time Remaining: 22d 11h 51m Buy It Now for only: $5.00 |
 West Liberty Ohio Postcard Fairyland Area Ohio Caverns Unused c1940s $4.00 Time Remaining: 22d 23h 40m Buy It Now for only: $4.00 |
 1908 North Liberty Ohio Real Photo Postcard Four Church Building RPPC w Postmark $9.00 Time Remaining: 25d 15h 22m Buy It Now for only: $9.00 |
 1923 MAC O CHEE CASTLE PLACE WEST LIBERTY OHIO $14.99 Time Remaining: 26d 17h 9m Buy It Now for only: $14.99 |
 Linen Postcard Ohio Caverns Crystal King West Liberty $3.95 Time Remaining: 27d 12h 10m Buy It Now for only: $3.95 |
 OH West Liberty Ohio RPPC Ohio Caverns $7.99 Time Remaining: 28d 17h 39m Buy It Now for only: $7.99 |
 OH West Liberty Ohio Mac O Chee Castle $5.99 Time Remaining: 28d 17h 59m Buy It Now for only: $5.99 |
 OH Liberty Center Ohio RPPC Main St Storefronts $34.99 Time Remaining: 28d 18h 55m Buy It Now for only: $34.99 |
 Old WOOSTER Ohio Postcard NIGHT Liberty St Hotel Wayne County $7.00 Time Remaining: 29d 6h 8m Buy It Now for only: $7.00 |
 Real photo pcOhio CavernsWest Liberty Ohioviews $3.49 Time Remaining: 29d 7h 11m Buy It Now for only: $3.49 |
 West Liberty Ohio Mac A Cheek Castle Real Photo $19.50 Time Remaining: 29d 17h 35m Buy It Now for only: $19.50 |